What is an EMC Risk Analysis?
The European EMC Directive (2014/30/EU) was updated in 2014, replacing the old directive (2008/108/EC) and became mandatory from April 2016 for any new product entering the EU from that date onwards. The change of directive was aimed at aligning the wording and terminology to ensure it was consistent with other CE Marking directives and implement standard text and modules laid out in the New Legislation Framework (NLF).
The principal objectives of the NLF were to:-
- Provide legislation governing products which should be clear and more consistent across sectors
- Clarify the obligations of all economic operators in the supply chain
- Make provisions such that products are more traceable
- Ensure that bodies which carry out conformity assessments should have certain attributes (e.g. independence and capability) and certain operational obligations
- Ensure that each Member State shall have robust, but proportionate, market surveillance and enforcement mechanisms in place based on a set of common requirements at the EU level.
As part of the changes that implement the above objectives, ‘risk’ was introduced into all the NLF affected directives, including the EMC Directive.
Risk however has multiple meanings within the directive ranging from risks associated with the product (which is the responsibility of the manufacturer); products that present a risk which is the responsibility of the market enforcement agencies and actions required by actors in the supply chain where risks have been identified.
What does ‘Risk’ mean in the context of EMC?
The EMC Directive requires that manufacturers ‘…shall include an adequate analysis and assessment of the risk(s)…’ but since the EMC directive is all about functionality and does not have any assessment of safety (including electromagnetic safety, which are covered by other CE Marking directives such as Low Voltage, Machinery Safety, Medical devices directive etc.), what type of risks are being assessed?
In order to answer this, it is firstly important to understand what a risk analysis and risk assessment are. Risk analysis is the process of identifying all of the potential EM hazards associated with both the product and the environment in which it is going to be used. For each of the risks that have been identified, their impact has to be assessed (risk evaluation). The combination of the risk analysis and evaluation is called the risk assessment.
If, as a result of this process, the residual risk is high, additional action is required to reduce the risk to a more acceptable level. This latter stage and taking into account information from other sources (articles in industry publications for example) and feedback from customers, focus groups etc. forms the risk management as illustrated in diagram 1.
Diagram 1 - Risk Assessment v Risk Management
Many of the hazards identified in a risk assessment will be covered by the application of an applicable ‘harmonized standard’. However it should be noted that not all hazards and hence risk will be covered in this process.
A harmonized standard provides a ‘presumption of conformity’ to the directive for areas that the standard covers but cannot be used to simply justify that the product will meet the requirements of the directive by simple application of the harmonized standard without further analysis.
By way of an illustrative example, a battery powered test equipment used for the logging of temperatures in a heating furnace in an industrial process may be assessed against the product specific standard, EN/IEC 61326-1 - Electrical equipment for measurement, control and laboratory use — EMC requirements — Part 1: General requirements.
This standard contains tests to assess the functionality of the product in the presence of radiated RF fields from intentional transmitters and ISM devices in the frequency range above 80MHz (EN/IEC 61000-4-3). It also defines test requirements for the assessment of RF transmitters and ISM devices below 80MHz (down to 150kHz) and uses the standard EN/IEC 61000-4-6 for this.
The problem is that EN/IEC 61000-4-6 is performed as a conducted assessment since the wavelengths below 80MHz are very long and conduction predominates over radiation.
Does that mean that a manufacturer can simply ignore the test and all frequencies below 80MHz? In short, no. The risk identification would (should) identify that fact that 27MHz is a well-used ISM frequency for the treatment of material and is used as the fundamental frequency for many RF heating applications. It will be known that there will be a significant EM field generated and yet there is no assessment if only the tests contained in the standard are performed. The manufacturer would identify this hazard and mitigate the risk by performing additional tests to supplement those defined in the harmonized standard, thus ensuring that the residual risk is low.
The above is just one example of where the application of a harmonized standard alone is not suitable for demonstrating compliance with the EMC Directive – there will be many more, based on the type and use of the product.
Here is another example, a tablet PC can be used in an environment other than the classic ‘domestic, commercial and light industrial’. Given that a manufacturer needs to think about both the use and also foreseen misuse (part of the risk analysis), it is certainly expected that this type of product will be used on a train, a vehicle or much closer proximity to a cellular device than the product specific standard (CISPR 35/EN55035) anticipates. The close proximity of higher power transmitters to products results in the product being exposed to higher levels of EM radiation than the standard covers. All these situations are foreseen and should be covered in the risk assessment.
Most conducted emissions standards start from 150kHz however there is an increasing amount of electrical noise generated below this frequency. Electric vehicle chargers, inverters for PV installations and the like all use switching technologies in the low kHz region and produce potentially significant EM emissions. Very few EMC standards require testing below 150kHz due to the unknown compatibility levels (this is a standards body related issue) but there is significant noise being generated and a lack of immunity tests in the standards to mitigate the risks.
It is important for EM hazards to be considered as part of the overall risk assessment of the product. The safety related community is very familiar with safety related risk assessments and is normally based around a wide selection of people with differing focus. EM knowledge unfortunately is not normally well represented meaning that EMC safety risks are often overlooked.
Before any EMC testing is performed, it should be considered in parallel with the EM safety aspects. EMC testing for functionality would require the product to be operating in its normal mode(s) whereas EM Safety testing would require a different set of parameters to be assessed (such as a product with an electronic power switch, switching ‘on’ when it should be ‘off’) which would require the standby mode to be assessed as well.
Manufacturers need to ensure that an EM risk analysis and assessment is performed as part of complying with the EMC Directive. The risk assessment needs to be documented and include the justification that leads to the overall residual risk.
Only the tests contained in harmonized standards provide a presumption of conformity for the parameters that they cover and a manufacturer should supplement these with their overall risk management to ensure that other hazards are identified and assessed accordingly.
Risk assessments are not something that can be subcontracted out from a manufacturer since the overall risk always has to lie with them. Understanding EM hazards and how to mitigate these risks however is something that can be outsourced and irrespective of who does it, should be considered as part of the overall risk assessment during the product realization phase of bringing a product to market.
If you would like specialist support to ensure that you meet all of your EMC obligations, please contact us or call UK +44 808 234 1667 or US +1888 786 7555.
More from Element
Element is one of the largest independent EMC testing company's in the world. Find out about our comprehensive testing capabilities in the UK and USA.
CE Marking and Testing
CE marking is a mandatory conformity mark enabling you to enjoy free movement between all 28 Member states.
Learn more about our laboratories - where they are located; the unique capabilities they have and how they can help you solve your technical and commercial challenges.
Discover perspectives, resources, and advice from our world-leading Engaged Experts.