Charpy vs. Izod: An Impact Testing Comparison
Both Charpy and Izod impact testing are popular methods of determining impact strength, or toughness, of a material. In other words, these tests measure the total amount of energy that a material is able to absorb. This energy absorption is directly related to the brittleness of the material. Brittle materials, such as ceramics or glass, tend to have lower absorption rates than ductile materials like copper or aluminum.
Understanding a material’s energy absorption properties is critical, as it predicts how much plastic deformation the material will be able to withstand before catastrophic failure. It is also important to understand the similarities and differences between these two common impact test methods.
Charpy Impact Testing
The Charpy impact test was developed by S.B. Russell and Georges Charpy at the turn of the 20th century. It remains to this day one of the most popular impact testing methods due to the relative ease of creating samples and obtaining results. The test apparatus consists of a weighted pendulum, which is dropped from a specified height to make contact with the specimen. The energy transferred to the material can be inferred by comparing the difference in the height of the pendulum before and after the fracture.
A Charpy test specimen, which is placed horizontally into the machine, is typically a 55 x 10 x 10mm (2.165" x 0.394" x 0.394") bar with a notch machined into one of the faces. This notch, which can be either V-shaped or U-shaped, is placed facing away from the pendulum and helps to concentrate the stress and encourage fracture. Testing can be performed at both ambient and reduced temperatures, sometimes as low as -425F.
Charpy impact testing is most commonly performed to ASTM E23, ASTM A370, ISO 148, or EN 10045-1. While the test is most commonly performed on metals, there are also a number of standards that exist for plastics and polymers, including ASTM D6110 and ISO 179.
Izod Impact Testing
The Izod impact test was named for English engineer Edwin Gilbert Izod, who first described the test method in 1903. The test apparatus and specimen design are very similar to Charpy impact, with some notable differences, including the orientation of the specimen, which is clamped into the apparatus vertically with the notch facing toward the pendulum. The pendulum then impacts the sample at a specified area above the notch.
One of the main differences from Charpy impact is that Izod impact testing can be performed on either plastic or metallic specimens. Plastic samples are typically a 64 x 12.7 x 3.2 mm bar with a machined V-shaped notch. Metallic samples are typically round 127 x 11.43 mm bar with 1 or 3 machined V-shaped notch(es).
Common Izod impact test methods include ASTM D256, ASTM E23, and ISO 180.
I have metallic samples. Which method should I perform?
While both the Izod and Charpy methods measure similar properties, the specimen design and testing configuration are different enough that care should be taken when choosing with method to perform. Your testing provider should be able to provide method recommendations based on your end goals and specific material in question.
Should you decide to perform Izod impact, you will need to decide on which specimen configuration to use. There are varying configurations of round specimens versus square specimens and single notched specimens versus those with up to three notches. Since it is often required to average 3 results for impact testing, the 3 notch specimen could be more economical, as it will take less material to get three impact results. Another possible advantage of the 3 notch sample is that the final result can be an average of directions depending on the specimen configuration. This could help eliminate bias caused by directional properties if this is a concern for your material.
Summary: What Are the Main Differences Between Charpy and Izod Impact Testing?
Ready to request a quote?
Our deliverable is certainty - high quality data, test reports and certificates that you can absolutely rely on when making decisions about your materials and compliance. Engage with an expert today.
More from Element
Find out about the complete range of impact testing services that area available from Elements worldwide network of Aerospace accredited laboratories
Our materials testing labs are staffed by Engaged Experts working tirelessly to solve our clients' most complex technical and commercial challenges.
Local laboratories, global platform
Doing business with one of our laboratories enables our clients' access to our global platform of expertise, capacity and capabilities.
Discover white papers, resources, and advice from our world-leading Engaged Experts.