Article

What is Mechanical Testing and Why is it Important throughout the Product Lifecycle?

By:  Malc Perry, MEng, Application Sales Engineer/Senior Metallurgist

Barry Ward BEng(Hons), CEng, MIMMM, Technical Director

Mechanical testing is a standard and essential part of any design and manufacturing process. Whether it is characterizing the properties of materials or providing validation for final products, ensuring safety is the primary mission of all mechanical testing. Testing also plays a crucial role in ensuring a cost-effective design as well as technological evolution and superiority. 

Origins of test requirements 

The test methodologies required are characteristically specified on drawings of the parts, which means that the testing responsibility falls to the manufacturer contracted for that part. 

Testing requirements are not always set by governing bodies; experienced design and manufacturing teams also understand the value of testing to validate models, make improvements, and increase the overall quality of parts. When faced with the cost and time implications of testing, it may seem like this process is expensive. However, it is an excellent place to start when it comes to reducing costs as unanticipated failures when the parts are in service have higher cost and time implications. 

Common types of testing 

The process starts with a review of the drawing or part specification to identify appropriate test methods, which can include: 

Model generation and validation

When it comes to streamlining the design process, solid modeling of components and assemblies, along with Finite Element Analysis (FEA), are excellent tools for engineers. Often the purpose of mechanical testing is to generate the data required by these FEA programs to generate the initial component models. That being said, FEA models do not guarantee accurate results, so the most practical approach is to :

  1. Develop a robust model from the materials testing data for the material
  2. Perform FEA to determine theoretical stress levels and locations, and
  3. Use product qualification testing or materials testing on component cut-ups (First Article Inspection) to validate the FEA model.

Since mechanical testing provides empirical data, it can be used to then go back and refine the FEA model. Once this step has been achieved, making design modifications in the model is much easier and more reliable without the added time and cost of numerous prototype and test iterations. 

Tensile testing

Raw material lots are liable to variability, so tensile testing of each lot ensures that it meets minimum strength and ductility requirements. Although material suppliers are equipped to handle these tests, it is recommended that they use a third-party laboratory test as independent and additional confirmation. Confirming that raw material is within acceptable limits is one of the easiest and most cost-effective assurances against future problems. 

Chemical analysis

Chemical analysis is also essential for both material and product manufacturers as it identifies the contents and quality of materials used in manufacturing and product development. During the early stages of the product development process, it is essential to verify materials to avoid any in-service failures.

Hardness
Hardness testing is required after production and also where heat treating is needed to verify conformance. Like tensile testing, this is a speedy and inexpensive testing option and does not usually require the final part to undergo destructive testing. 

Fatigue testing

In the majority of applications, the objective of fatigue testing is to develop a fatigue strength curve that characterizes the material's ability to resist cyclic loading over fluctuating stress levels or to establish the operating conditions when fatigue would not be experienced in the components lifetime. Once this curve is established, the results are compared to the criteria of the part design to make sure that the material will enable the component to fulfill its projected life expectancy. 

Final part geometry can make it challenging to apply raw material fatigue data due to complex dimensional features such as notches and holes. When this is the case, it is recommended that the final part undergoes fatigue testing. Going a step beyond the previous methods discussed, this may require a more sophisticated test setup and include the destruction of some production parts. The upside to this approach is that not only can a fatigue strength curve be generated, but failure modes will be determined. This knowledge is valuable for design improvements and maintenance schedules. 

Fatigue and fracture mechanics
Fatigue and fracture mechanics provides data about a material's capability to withstand flaws and the effect on its strength. When it comes to developing maintenance programs and predicting the service life of components, fatigue, and fracture mechanics testing is an extremely popular tool. Some machine components will inevitably develop cracks in their lifetime. Replacing parts can be extremely costly and, in many cases, completely unnecessary; the key is to determine the severity of the flaw and to recognize when it crosses the line to become a critical matter. 

Fatigue and fracture mechanics are made up of many different types of static and dynamic tests that characterize a material's resistance to crack growth fracture toughness once a flaw has originated. This knowledge of how a material will react under such conditions enables engineers to estimate the life of the component. It means that, in some cases, costly repairs can be postponed to a time convenient to schedule the work. Knowing which materials have higher fracture toughness can improve designs, and prolong component life expectancy. 

Stress rupture and creep testing
Stress rupture is also essential throughout the product lifecycle. It provides critical information for engineers, enabling them to prevent failures by giving insights into the effect of long-term stress on materials and products. 

Is testing worth the investment?

As product testing often involves specialized test equipment, custom-fabricated fixtures, skilled test engineers, and extra products and materials devoted to testing, it requires investment from organizations. When today's competitive marketplace is taken into account, this investment can be difficult to justify at the start of a project when budgets are already squeezed. However, it cannot be underestimated that the failure to perform appropriate testing can have devastating consequences that can cost significantly more than the testing itself. 

Here, we take a look at some of the actual costs that organizations face if they decide to forego testing: 

Internal audit

 The first and least costly consequence of avoiding testing is the internal discovery of nonconformance through an internal audit or quality check. In terms of scenarios, this is not the worst-case as the product has not yet left the premises, meaning the damage is limited. This situation can be alleviated by separating the affected products, evaluating for conformance, and, if necessary, making the required reworks. 

Failed audit

Being subjected to findings from an audit is one of the more severe consequences of avoiding testing requirements. Any errors discovered at this stage could be rectified as the affected products can be recalled and evaluated, and reworks and repairs carried out for the products to be re-released. However, as well as the time and cost implications, organizations risk losing a customer's trust and potentially valuable contracts. 

Increased costs
If a lack of accurate models are utilized, products and components can often be over-engineered, making them more expensive. Using appropriate models and designing components based on empirical testing data, the lead time for creating components can be reduced. 

Product failure 

 The most costly consequence of not testing is catastrophic product failure. The result of this can be devastating, ranging from product damage to loss of life, and the consequences are permanent with organizations exposed to legal prosecution. 

Rest assured that, thanks to thorough quality checks, product failure rarely occurs. However, this should be no comfort to the quality engineer whose responsibility is to ensure absolute product conformance at every stage of a project and product lifecycle. By providing strong in-house testing capabilities and partnering with an accredited laboratory, organizations can help to ensure continuity and quality every step of the way. 

Working to prevent future failure
Should products fail during the testing phase or in-service, failure analysis is a critical aspect of product development and system improvement, which not only helps us learn from the past, but helps prevent future failures.

Failure analysis is a multi-faceted, holistic approach to determine how and why a material or product failed. The initial stage of any investigation involves an in-depth discovery phase of the circumstances surrounding the failure and any relevant background information, including environmental factors, type of application, service life, and pertinent design information. Element's failure analysts then apply a wide variety of analytical methods and tools to inspect the failed part.

Based on findings from the failure analysis process, Element experts provide recommendations and work closely with the customer to find solutions to problems for a diverse range of products and materials. The combination of our materials expertise and our knowledge of what impact the service environment can have on a material or product enables the rapid delivery of comprehensive results.

While identifying the root cause and associated responsibility of any failure are the primary goals, the added value is provided in preventing future occurrences.

The Element advantage

Element provides a range of mechanical testing capabilities for metallic and nonmetallic materials to ensure products are cost-effective and technologically advanced as well as remain safe and fit-for-purpose throughout their lifecycle. Whether testing to a standard method or developing a custom program, our experts can provide you with accurate, reliable results for projects large and small. Contact our colleagues for more information.

Find related articles to you through the Nucleus

Get white papers, articles, webinars, and event invites from our experts

Subscribe to Element's resources

Cta_Small_1600x480

Our team of over 6,700 Engaged Experts in North America, Europe, The Middle East, Australia, Asia and Africa are ready to help you.